I’ve been a fan of Riley Sager’s books since I first read Final Girls and then his follow-up, The Last Time I Lied, which is my favorite. With every book released, I have enjoyed each one. I always know what to expect going in and have fun coming up with theories as I read while also yelling at the page a few times proclaiming that a character had done it even if I was later proven wrong (or right).
When I read Sager’s last book, The House Across The Lake, I was a little disappointed despite being intrigued by the plot. So, I admit I went into The Only One Left a little apprehensive. However, just like everything that happens in it, I was left floored and flabbergasted. Most of all, I thought he had gone back to what had made his earlier books so twisty and engaging.
In 1929, Lenora Hope was accused of murdering her whole family. Decades later her story has been immortalized into a chant while she continues to reside in the mansion that rests upon the edge of a cliff holding all the secrets of that very night. Now it’s 1983, and Kit McDeere is a caregiver assigned to take care of Lenora, who is ready to tell Kit the whole truth.
If you’ve read Sager’s books, you know how he likes to play around with thriller tropes. In The Only One Left he takes inspiration from the infamous Lizzie Borden. I really like the mystery surrounding Lenora Hope and how it’s revealed through the typewritten messages she writes to Kit. Kit, as the audience surrogate, turns out to be just as unreliable of a narrator as Lenora, but it also strengthens their relationship and why they would trust and question each other.
It gets a little muddled and convoluted near the end with twist after twist that I had to pause and reevaluate everything. Once I caught up though, it’s a wild ending and a satisfying read, which I’m still thinking about.